Why Willpower Can’t Fix Hormone Imbalance in Menopause

Apple Podcast - Spotify - YouTube

If you’ve ever stood in your kitchen staring at your food, your supplements, or even your own reflection and thought, “How am I a capable grown woman who suddenly can’t figure out what to eat?” — I want you to take a deep breath. You’re not losing your mind. And you’re definitely not alone. Menopause has a way of catching even the strongest, most organized women off guard. Hormone imbalance brings a kind of internal chaos that can shake your confidence and make simple decisions feel surprisingly heavy.

I hear it every week in my coaching calls. Women who’ve raised large families, run businesses, supervised dozens of employees, homeschooled children, managed chronic illnesses, served in ministry — women who have done hard things for decades — suddenly hit perimenopause or menopause and think, “Why can’t I do what I used to do?” And the quiet fear underneath that question is just as heavy: “What’s wrong with me?”

The truth is nothing is wrong with you. Your body is simply shifting into a new season, a midlife season that requires a different level of partnership, a different pace, and a different kind of care. And today, I want to invite you into my story — the moment I hit my own wall and the slow, faith-filled journey that helped me step into peace instead of pressure.

The Moment Menopause Flipped My World Upside Down

I’ll never forget the morning everything came crashing in. It was entirely ordinary: quiet time finished, supplements lined up like little soldiers, oatmeal simmering on the stove. My routine. My rhythm. My comfort. And then, without warning, I felt it — that deep emotional wave rising up, the kind that catches you off guard and makes you feel like your insides are coming undone.

Before I could talk myself out of it, tears spilled. I found myself whispering to the Lord, “I’m doing all the things… but I don’t even know if I’m doing the needed thing.” That sentence came straight from the ache in my chest. I wasn’t failing for lack of trying. I was exhausted from trying everything. I was drowning in information, overwhelmed by comparison, and still completely unsure whether anything I was doing was actually helping.

In the middle of that quiet, tear-soaked moment, I sensed Him speak something simple and freeing: “Let go.”
Not “give up,” but “release.” Not collapse, but surrender. It felt like He placed a bundle of helium balloons in my hands — perfection, control, timelines, expectations — and invited me to open my fingers and watch them float upward.

It wasn’t a one-time act but a practice… one I still return to.

Why Willpower Stops Working in Menopause

For most of our adult lives, we’ve been taught that willpower is the answer. Push harder. Try more. Be disciplined. Stick to the plan. And for a long time, that works… until menopause enters the chat.

When hormones start fluctuating and declining, everything from your brain to your energy to your emotional resilience gets affected. Estrogen, progesterone, testosterone, insulin, cortisol, leptin, and ghrelin all have jobs — quiet, behind-the-scenes jobs that keep your mental clarity steady, your sleep predictable, your cravings manageable, your metabolism humming, and your stress responses balanced. When they shift, your whole internal operating system shifts with them.

This is why so many women tell me they feel more emotional, more overwhelmed, more easily stressed, or more forgetful. This is why you can’t “power through” the way you used to. It’s also why your old strategies — skipping meals, eating less, cutting carbs, over-exercising, hustling harder — backfire in this season. Willpower wasn’t designed to fix hormone imbalance. And menopause isn’t something you push through; it’s something you partner with.

Instead of feeling like your body is fighting you, this is the moment to get curious. To listen. To honor what your body is asking for instead of forcing her back into a mold that no longer fits.

The Shift From Fighting to Partnering

Once I stopped resisting my midlife body and started paying attention to her cues, something beautiful began to happen. Not instantly. Not dramatically. But consistently over time.

I realized I needed to fuel differently. My body was asking for more protein — not just a sprinkle, but enough to trigger muscle repair and steady my blood sugar. That shift to 25–35 grams per meal was a turning point because, in menopause, muscle loss accelerates, metabolism slows, and energy dips. Without adequate protein, everything feels harder.

I also had to stop treating carbohydrates like the enemy. In this season, your body loses the natural energy boost estrogen used to provide. Wise carb pairing isn’t indulgence; it’s support — especially for thyroid health, blood sugar balance, and consistent energy. My fatigue made so much more sense once I realized my body wasn’t malfunctioning; it was signaling.

And then there was strength training. As a personal trainer, I lived and breathed fitness, yet even I had to unlearn some old patterns. Cardio has its place, but strength training is what rebuilds metabolism, protects bones, maintains insulin sensitivity, and reduces symptoms of menopause. It’s how you reshape your body from the inside out.

But even with fueling and training shifts, there was another piece I couldn’t ignore: my nervous system. Menopause demanded more rest, more recovery, and more boundaries. It asked me to slow down. To breathe. To stop running from myself. To trust that rest was not laziness but stewardship.

That was the hardest part — and the most transformational.

The Faith Piece: Learning From Mary and Martha

There’s a story I return to often: Mary sitting at Jesus’ feet while Martha hustles in the kitchen. For years, I identified with Martha — productive, responsible, always moving, always doing. But I began to realize that both Mary and Martha live inside me. One wants to serve; one wants to sit. One wants to control; one wants to surrender.

Menopause forced me to let my Mary lead more often. It didn’t mean abandoning responsibility; it meant honoring presence over performance. It meant asking the Lord what the needed thing was instead of everything. It meant learning that saying yes to everything is actually the enemy of excellence in this season. And it meant accepting that my worth is not measured in output.

Midlife invited me into humility — not humiliation, but holy humility. The kind that says, “Lord, lead me. I don’t have to figure this out alone.”

Slow Transformation Is Still Transformation

Once I began making these shifts, things started to change. My energy slowly improved. My brain fog lifted bit by bit. My hunger signals felt more predictable. My workouts made a bigger impact. I started sleeping better in certain seasons. And more than anything, my heart softened toward this new version of myself.

I stopped shaming my midlife body for changing.
I stopped comparing her to my 30-year-old self.
I stopped expecting her to keep up with an old pace that was never meant for this season.

My body wasn’t the enemy. She was the messenger. And partnering with her instead of fighting her made all the difference.

When You’re Unsure What to Do Next

If something in this story hits home for you — if your spirit feels tender or your mind feels relieved to finally understand what’s been happening — I want you to pause and ask yourself one gentle question:

“What is my next step to partner with my body in this season?”

Not all the steps.
Not the perfect plan.
Just the next step.

Maybe it’s eating enough protein.
Maybe it’s strength training twice a week.
Maybe it’s honoring your bedtime.
Maybe it’s slowing down.
Maybe it’s surrender.

And if you need structure and support — if you’re tired of trying to figure it all out alone — I’d love to help you inside my Midlife Fat Loss Formula program, where we walk through these shifts step by step.

Menopause isn’t a downfall; it’s an invitation. Hormone imbalance isn’t a failure; it’s a nudge toward a wiser, more intentional way of caring for your body. You don’t have to push harder. You don’t have to earn your way back to who you used to be. You simply get to meet the woman you are now — with compassion, strategy, and surrendered strength.