3 Lies About Hormones Sabotaging Weight Loss After 40

Apple Podcast - Spotify - YouTube

Why You’re Gaining Belly Fat Even When You’re Eating Clean and Following THM

You're Not Crazy—You're Hormonal (But That’s Not the Whole Story)

If you’re doing everything “right”—following the Trim Healthy Mama plan, skipping sugar, working out, eating clean—and you’re still gaining belly fat, this post is for you. I talk to midlife women every single day in my coaching programs, in my free Menopause Makeover community, and on discovery calls—and I hear the same frustrations on repeat.

“I feel like I’m gaining weight on air.”
“My doctor says my hormones are fine, but I can’t lose a pound.”
“I’m doing everything and the scale won’t move.”

If that’s you, take a deep breath, friend. You're not alone—and you're not broken. You're just believing a few common hormone lies that keep women stuck in midlife. Let's call them out and replace them with the truth that actually moves the needle on fat loss, energy, and healing—without burnout.

Lie #1: It’s Just Calories In, Calories Out

This is the one that makes my blood boil just a little. So many women tell me their doctors say, “You just need to eat less and exercise more.” And while I’m not here to throw shade at your doctor (they’re doing the best they can with the training they’ve been given), this advice is just flat-out outdated for women in perimenopause and menopause.

Here's the truth:

Your body isn’t a simple math equation.
It's a complex hormonal system that needs fuel, not restriction.

When you drastically cut calories—like 1,200 or even 1,000 per day—your body goes into stress mode. Sure, you might lose a few pounds of water and even some fat at first, but your body also starts breaking down muscle, which is exactly what you need to boost metabolism and burn fat.

Why low-calorie diets fail women in midlife:

• They trigger muscle loss
  
• They slow down metabolism
  
• They raise cortisol, which stores belly fat
  
• They disrupt hormone function (especially thyroid and adrenals)
  
• They leave you feeling tired, foggy, and ready to binge by the weekend
  
  

Instead of cutting calories, focus on fueling your body with balance and purpose—which is exactly what Trim Healthy Mama teaches us when we use single fuels and pair meals wisely.

Lie #2: Hormone Therapy Will Make Weight Loss Easy

Let’s get real about this one. I love bioidentical hormone replacement therapy when it’s needed—it can be a game-changer for quality of life. It can help stabilize mood, protect your bones and heart, improve sleep, and ease hot flashes.

But here’s the deal: hormones are not magic for weight loss.

If you’re relying on BHRT to fix belly fat without addressing food, movement, or lifestyle stressors, you're going to be disappointed.

What hormones can do:

• Support your metabolism
  
• Help reduce inflammation
  
• Improve sleep and stress resilience (which helps with insulin sensitivity)
  
  

But you still have to:

• Eat balanced, protein-anchored meals
• Move daily and build muscle
• Get enough sleep
• Lower stress
• Support your gut and liver

It’s the whole picture that turns on fat burning, not just one supplement or patch.

Lie #3: Carbs Are the Enemy in Menopause

Listen, I know the low-carb and keto world is LOUD. And yes, if you’re eating a bunch of white bread and sugar, that’s not going to help your hormones or waistline. But swinging to the other extreme—cutting out carbs completely—is one of the most harmful things a woman in midlife can do.

Here’s why: your adrenal glands and thyroid need good carbs to function.
Carbs help calm your nervous system, support serotonin, and fuel your workouts.

If you're dragging through your day, waking up tired, and craving all the things at night, your body might be begging for some well-timed, hormone-supporting E (energizing carb-based) meals.

What good carbs do for midlife women:

• Support cortisol balance
  
• Stabilize blood sugar when paired with protein
  
• Help regulate thyroid and mood
  
• Prevent binge-eating later in the day
  
• Keep energy up without stimulants
  
  

Instead of fearing carbs, learn how to use them wisely with the THM (Trim Healthy Mama )plan:
Have them with protein, pair with non-starchy veggies, and avoid stacking with fats.

So What Does Work for Midlife Fat Loss?

I’m glad you asked. Here’s the formula that actually works for women over 40 (and I teach this inside my Midlife Fat Loss Formula program):

✓  Protein Anchored Meals

Aim for 25–35 grams of protein at every meal to fuel muscle, support hormones, and stabilize blood sugar.

✓  Balanced Fuels

Use the THM method to separate your fats and carbs for metabolic flexibility—don’t fear either!

✓  Build Muscle

Muscle is your metabolic gold mine. It helps you absorb glucose, burn more calories at rest, and protects your bones and joints.

✓  Eat Enough

Stop starving your body. Eat square, satisfying meals with whole food ingredients and plenty of plants.

✓  Support Insulin Sensitivity

It’s not about “eating less.” It’s about getting your insulin working again. That means no sugar bombs, no late-night snacking, and no skipping meals.

✓ Prioritize Sleep + Stress Management

Sleep deprivation and high cortisol are the silent saboteurs of belly fat. Set a bedtime. Breathe. Say no more often.

Healing Takes Time—But It’s Possible

Maybe you’ve dieted your metabolism into the ground. Maybe you feel like nothing works anymore. But I want you to hear this: healing is possible. You’re not beyond repair. You just need to stop hustling for quick fixes and start giving your body the inputs it needs to feel safe, strong, and supported again.

God often does His best work in the process—not the perfection. And this journey? It’s not about chasing skinny. It’s about becoming strong, calm, and confident in a body you enjoy living in.

Belly fat in midlife isn’t just about calories—it’s about hormones, muscle, and healing your metabolism. Stop believing the lies that you have to starve yourself, skip carbs, or rely solely on hormones. You need a whole-body approach that honors your changing needs, fuels you well, and supports your healing journey step-by-step.